Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5] 6 7 ... 9   Go Down
Print
Author Topic: Scientology under fire in Aus  (Read 2693 times)
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #60 on: March 10, 2010, 02:42:53 PM »

                        Australian of the Year backs Scientology inquiry
10 Mar, 2010


Australian of the Year Pat McGorry has backed calls for a Senate inquiry into Scientology, saying its views on mental health are putting lives at risk.

"They are the deniers of the realities of mental illness, which I find incredibly irresponsible and dangerous," he told ABC Radio today.

The renowned mental health expert has joined psychiatry boss Louise Newman and the Brain and Mind Institute's Ian Hickie in urging senators to vote for an inquiry.

The Senate is expected to vote on the issue, brought forward by independent senator Nick Xenophon, by the end of next week.

Professor McGorry met Senator Xenophon yesterday to lend his voice to the cause.

"I'm concerned that any restriction or any discouragement of access to mental health care will cost lives and result in unnecessary disability for people," he said.

"The whole mental health field would support this call for an inquiry and it's something that's overdue in my opinion."

So far, only the Australian Greens have committed to voting for the inquiry and it needs more support if it's to get up.

Senator Xenophon said the church had nothing to fear from a transparent inquiry where it would be given the right of reply.

He said he would not abandon any victims of Scientology, adding he could be a "completely stubborn bastard" when it came to pursuing important issues.

The church's Australian vice-president Cyrus Brooks has rejected the support of the mental health experts.

"That's the wrong way for them to go there. They're going into the field of religion and they're in the field of mental health," he said.

http://www.independentweekly.com.au/news/national/national/general/australian-of-the-year-backs-scientology-inquiry/1772083.aspx?src=rss

and here...  Adelaide Now
http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news/national/scientology-putting-lives-at-risk-says-australian-of-the-year-pat-mcgorry/story-e6frea8c-1225838942141

and here...

ABC News...

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/03/10/2841369.htm?section=justin

More plus video...

http://forums.whyweprotest.net/318-senator-xenophon-scientology/psychs-scientology-putting-lives-risk-62786/
« Last Edit: March 10, 2010, 06:12:09 PM by Ididntcomeback » Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #61 on: March 10, 2010, 06:05:45 PM »

 Do you think Scientology puts lives at risk ?

59936  yes
 6175    no.

Have your say.  Well ? What`s the answer ?
http://ninemsn.com.au/
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #62 on: March 10, 2010, 09:54:03 PM »

                 Senator Nick Xenophone Interviewed on radio

  5.1 MB MP3 download..

http://forums.whyweprotest.net/318-senator-xenophon-scientology/xenophon-interview-re-4corners-2ue-62774/
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #63 on: March 11, 2010, 09:40:26 PM »

                         Rudd, Abbott 'running scared on Scientology'

By online political correspondent Emma Rodgers

Updated 7 hours 4 minutes ago
Another push for an inquiry is expected next week. (File photo)


Independent Senator Nick Xenophon has slammed the major parties for blocking his moves for an inquiry into the Church of Scientology.

Senator Xenophon has been calling for a full inquiry into the church since revealing claims of forced abortions and other abuses in Parliament last year.

Today he accused Prime Minister Kevin Rudd of hiding behind process and vowed to continue to fight for further examination of Scientology in Australia.

"There is a certain cowardice in turning your backs on people who ask for help and ask just to be heard," he said.

"I ask Kevin Rudd and [Opposition Leader] Tony Abbott, what is it about forced abortions you do not want to know about?

"What is it about false imprisonment that you don't want to know about? I will not turn my backs on the victims of Scientology. I will not let this lie. This issue will not go away."

Senator Xenophon now says he will move another motion for an inquiry into the church, which he says will focus on specific allegations made against it, next week.

Today Senator Xenophon moved for a broader inquiry into the tax-free status of religions when it was clear he did not have the numbers for his original Scientology probe.

However, the Opposition and Government blocked the motion.

Senator Xenophon said the Government told him it could not support the tax inquiry because it could pre-empt the still-to-be released Henry Tax Review.

Special Minister of State Joe Ludwig says the tax-free status of various organisations has already been extensively covered by other inquiries and another is not needed.

"Based on this detailed and comprehensive record of an analysis and in light of two current review reports before the Government, we will not be supporting this motion today," he said.

The Greens supported the motion but that was not enough to get it passed.

"I do object and I know many other Australians object to millions of dollars being siphoned off from the public purse because we haven't refined our ability to say a dangerous cult ought not be getting that money," Greens leader Bob Brown said.

Liberal Senator Eric Abetz expressed sympathy for anyone who had suffered under the Church of Scientology but said the Senate was not the right place to hear their stories.

He also questioned whether a Senate inquiry would stop people being "brainwashed" by various organisations.

"Whilst the motion on the face of it looks relatively innocuous, talks about a general inquiry into matters tax and charitable status generally, there is no doubt from the speeches of Senators Xenophon and Brown ... that it would not just be a general discussion of matters taxation," he said.

ABC's Four Corners program also this week broadcast allegations from ex-members of Scientology of forced abortions, pressure to work extreme hours and being forced to hand over large sums of money.

More links here...

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/03/11/2842893.htm
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #64 on: March 12, 2010, 06:13:17 AM »

Two youtube links.

Senator Xenophon interviewed on ABC Radio

And

Xenophon`s Scientology inquiry blocked

http://www.forum.exscn.net/showthread.php?t=16827
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #65 on: March 12, 2010, 06:54:20 PM »


                               Xenophon vow on Scientology probe
KATHARINE MURPHY
March 12, 2010

Independent senator Nick Xenophon has vowed to continue his efforts to investigate the Church of Scientology after a motion for a Senate inquiry failed yesterday.

The federal government and the opposition declined to support yesterday's motion that would have triggered an inquiry into the tax status of religious organisations.

Senator Xenophon blasted the decision, calling the opposition ''pathetic''. ''There is a certain cowardice in turning your back on people who need help,'' he said during an occasionally fiery debate.

The South Australian independent has resolved to introduce a motion that would create a narrower inquiry examining Scientology practices rather than his broader proposal to inquire into tax arrangements for churches and charities.

Senator Xenophon last November raised explosive allegations about practices within the Church of Scientology, allegations the church has strenuously denied.

The inquiry he proposed yesterday would have provided a vehicle for complainants to air their grievances.

The Australian Greens yesterday backed his effort. Senator Bob Brown argued the Senate should be prepared to examine ''dangerous cults that take over people's lives''.

But the government said it would not support another inquiry into the tax treatment of religious groups.

The opposition said police should investigate any allegations of illegality, not Parliament. Liberal senator Eric Abetz said a free society allowed people to hold ''silly or dangerous views''.

The debate took an ugly turn when South Australian Liberal Cory Bernardi invoked a reference to the Nazis in order to criticise the Greens' stance. He withdrew the statement after an objection from Senator Brown.

Senator Bernardi then argued that an inquiry into Scientology would impinge on religious freedom.

http://www.theage.com.au/national/xenophon-vow-on-scientology-probe-20100311-q1pv.html
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #66 on: March 12, 2010, 07:54:45 PM »

                          Scientology insider's nightmare childhood

By Sarah Collerton

A former Scientologist who says she was a "child slave" and alleges she saw a six-year-old boy chained up in a ship's hold is disappointed the Senate has blocked a full inquiry into the religious organisation.

Independent Senator Nick Xenophon has been calling for a full inquiry into the church since revealing claims of forced abortions and other abuses in Parliament last year.

Keryn, 54, grew up in the church and has asked the ABC to identify her only by her first name.

She says she was a victim of "hard labour, mental brutality and separation" on Scientology ships, which were used for the Church's elite band of followers in the 1960s to 1970s. She is angry the motion for a Scientology probe has been blocked in Parliament.

"Australia is an egalitarian society; Scientology is not egalitarian," she told ABC News Online.

"There is no protection for workers and no protection for children. It's the push for the inquiry that has brought me out of the woodwork."

Keryn says her mother was a founding member of the church and went on to become the CEO of Scientology in South Africa.

"It should be banned; it's a very dangerous pseudo-religion and corporate enterprise, and it really needs to be looked at very closely," she said.

"If it's not looked at very closely and monitored and checks and balances put in place, then one day people are going to look back and say, 'This is bad news and we did nothing'.

"The structure is very totalitarian, and I just think it's very bad for mental health. They need to look into the separation of families. I know many broken families because of Scientology."

Keryn wants an inquiry to investigate living and labour conditions as well as schooling for children working for the organisation at a young age.

"There is a belief in Scientology that normal schooling simply indoctrinates you with social norms and ideologies ... so they prefer to indoctrinate with their own ideologies, with the result that Scientology children, if they manage to leave, are usually unskilled and uneducated.

"This forces them back into the world they know - in other words Scientology recreates its own labour force," she said.

"People just get so brainwashed and it's made so difficult for people to leave, they just don't. Staff members don't get paid so they can't accumulate money to leave.

"There's a belief system that if you find something wrong with Scientology, then there's something wrong with you. That's instilled in you so deeply that it's very hard to shake."

             'Nightmare' childhood

Keryn's decision to speak openly about her experiences comes after ABC1's Four Corners program, The Ex-Files, in which former members told of forced abortions, pressure to work extreme hours and being forced to hand over large sums of money.

Members of Scientology's elite unit of full-time staffers the Sea Organisation - or Sea Org - detailed allegations of a strict regime of discipline and punishment in place during the 1960s.

Scientology has denied the claims, but Keryn says she can back up the allegations.

She says she signed a billion-year contract as a 12-year-old, lived on the Scientology vessels The Royal Scotman and The Athena, and was in effect a "child slave".

"When we were on the ship, we had people working 20 hours a day, seven days a week," she said.

"It was a nightmare for me and my brother. For most of our lives, we were separated from our mother because she was in the Sea Org.

"A lot of the children hadn't seen their parents for months, and their parents were on the same ship."

She says what she saw happen to one child, a six-year-old boy named Larry, still haunts her today.

"I've carried him with me all my life and I want to put it on record what I saw," she said.

While working on one of the Sea Org boats, which was a former cattle ship, Keryn heard a clinking sound and found the boy in the hold.

"Larry was chained by his leg and he was there for a few days. He was fed, but he was chained," she said.

She says she was forced to "disconnect" from her father, who did not want to be part of the church.

"They say they don't break up families but they most definitely do," she said.

"[On Four Corners, Scientologist Tommy Davis] claimed they have no disconnection policy - that's an outright lie, unless they've changed that. I was told to disconnect from my father, that he would suppress us. I was told to write a letter to him when I was six to disconnect from him."

         L Ron Hubbard

Originally the prospect of "sailing the high seas, having adventures and not going to school anymore" was exciting to Keryn, but she soon realised the reality of life in the Sea Org. She says it was "worse than jail".

"My brother was allocated a job in the engine room of the shift as a greaser - he was 10 ... I was working in the canteen and we were both working 20-hour shifts," she said.

"I didn't see him for weeks and then one day I bumped into him in the doorways between the dormitories, and he was this little thing, covered in grease with these big red eyes, and he saw me and he started crying and he said he wanted to go home.

"At that stage, you could petition the commodore, who was L Ron Hubbard, who was living on the ship up in his luxury apartment. I petitioned him and he went home straightaway, but you had to have a replacement for him, so I took my brother's place in the engine room."

While Keryn was not aware of any forced abortions, she says she remembers cruel punishments such as people being locked in dark hatches and at other times being forced to do hard labour at "double time".

"One of the punishments they had was throwing you overboard, which happened to my mother on a regular basis," she said.

Those thrown overboard were rescued.

Keryn also knew Scientology founder L Ron Hubbard, and recalls seeing him around the ship in a "white sailor suit".

"He was a very powerful, enigmatic figure," she said.

"As an individual, he had a very powerful force about him and I could see people would quiver in his presence, he had immense self-belief. In the flesh, he didn't wander around like some demented, nutty professor."

           Tracking her down

Keryn, who moved from South Africa to Australia in 1989, worked on the ships until she was 13, when she was "rescued" by her grandmother.

For years, she has kept the torment to herself and only occasionally spoken about it to her brother, who is still bitter and angry about their upbringing.

She did not want to speak publicly out of fear and "conflicted loyalty" to her mother, who stayed a devout Scientologist until she died.

Keryn was left frightened after Scientologists tracked her down on Facebook and called her, 42 years after she left the organisation.

"I thought it was well and truly behind me," she said.

She also says they have been harassing her brother, who still lives in South Africa, calling him day and night.

         Big business

Keryn says over the years Scientology has changed from the more idealistic early days.

"They've really refined their acts and become very slick at marketing and promotions and corporate management," she said.

"They're still doing what they've always done, but they've just morphed into something slicker so they're much more dangerous than they were before.

"I'm really nervous about where it's going - it's just infiltrated so many educational programs, management programs."

What makes Keryn very angry is the celebrity following.

"When I hear John Travolta and Tom Cruise come out and say 'this is the way', I think 'have you actually ever been behind the scenes of the Celebrity Centre to see how they live?' They don't," she said.

"The hard work is done by staff members. The people that have money do what people with money always do. They just throw money at stuff and people are nice to them. And Scientology has always courted celebrities because that is their legitimisation and it's working.

"If there's one thing I can say though, because Tom Cruise jumped on that stupid couch, that actually started the ridicule, and the ridicule has grown bigger and bigger and started to undermine Scientology's image."

             Scientology 'has changed'

The ABC has approached the Church of Scientology about Keryn's claims.

Scientology's Australia spokesman Cyrus Brooks says after the Sea Org was formed in 1967, it "took several years to settle itself" and "there were a few staff who were violating the church policy at that time".

"What we have today is far from its earliest days," he said.

"As we have grown and evolved, we have formulated strict regulations as to conduct of staff and conditions and we also have a much firmer screening policy of those who apply and join."

He says children have not been allowed to join the Sea Org for more than 20 years, however the ABC's Four Corners investigation found members have been recruited and separated from their families from the age of 14 since then.

Mr Brooks says the Sea Org's 5,000 members, who are now on dry land, do not get paid.

"We don't expect a wage and we don't do it for a wage. We know this before we join and it is a major decision to do so," he said.

"We understand that we are going to be working almost full time - including a work day, along then with religious studies and practice daily."

Mr Brooks says if members are in touch with people the church opposes, they cannot go to church services.

"If a current member by way of family connection or another relationship is connected with someone who is violently opposed to Scientology and engaging in conduct to attack the church, we state that while the upset remains, they are unable to have church services until they resolve the situation," he said.

"A person who is connected with someone against their religious faith by experience does not make spiritual gains, as any gains they make are invalidated by the antagonistic source."

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/03/12/2844150.htm?section=justin
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #67 on: March 15, 2010, 12:22:09 AM »

                       Govt urged to back Scientology inquiry

Sydney Morning Herald
SUSANNA DUNKERLEY
March 13, 2010

AAP

Pressure is mounting on the federal government and opposition to agree to an inquiry into the Church of Scientology, amid claims they are shielding it from abuse allegations for political reasons.

Social commentator Phillip Adams has accused the two major political parties of turning a blind eye to the issue after they joined forces to vote down a parliamentary inquiry into the church's, and other charities', tax-free status last week.

Speaking at the Global Atheist Convention in Melbourne, Mr Adams said Scientology was a pseudo-religion that shouldn't enjoy charity status in Australia.

He said Australia should follow the example of the United Kingdom, where a strict public-benefit test applies.

"To hear those idiots in the Senate talking about Scientology as a religion when it's a racket is ludicrous," he said at what organisers called the largest gathering ever held in Australia under the banner of atheism.

"It just makes you realise how wonderfully protected the group actually is."

Mr Adams told the audience of atheists, sceptics, humanists, feminists and secularists that Scientology was "a dreadful outfit of excesses and cruelties".

"And here in Australia we are continuing to turn a blind eye to it."

Independent senator Nick Xenophon, who called for the inquiry, will try to launch another one this week focusing on allegations against the church, including claims of forced abortions, imprisonment in boot camps and separation of families.

Former Australian Democrats leader Lyn Allison, who is also speaking at the three-day conference, says she doubts the inquiry will get up.

Politicians were scared the challenge to tax-free status would spread to other religions, the former senator said.

"Whilst individually they (the government and coalition) probably don't like Scientology, they do not want to open up Pandora's box," she told AAP.

Ms Allison, who now works for a number of human rights groups, was critical of the federal government's position that an inquiry was not needed because the tax-free status of charities was already being looked at through ongoing tax inquiries.

"We've had tax inquiries in the past, and the findings were that there was no case for revisiting the tax exemptions for charities. Any new inquiry is unlikely to be any different," Ms Allison said.

Fellow presenter Max Wallace, who has written extensively about tax exemption for religious groups in Australia, says tens of millions of dollars in taxpayers' money is handed to the churches each year.

"Exemption from taxation for churches is a 17th century idea that has no bearing on the 21st century," he told the conference.

But he noted one anomaly in Australia, the UFO-based religion known as Raelianism.

"The Raelians believe that there are extraterrestrial beings in another galaxy. The tax office decided that because those extraterrestrial beings were material, and not supernatural, it didn't fall into the definition of religion for tax exemption."

The conference, including talks by popular science writer and atheist Richard Dawkins and controversial ethicist Peter Singer, continues. All 2500 tickets to the March 12-14 event sold out in advance.

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/govt-urged-to-back-scientology-inquiry-20100313-q4rq.html
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #68 on: March 17, 2010, 11:59:05 PM »

                                   The herald Sun

               Former Scientologists keen to spill beans on church to Rudd, Abbott

    * From: AAP
    * March 17, 2010 10:15AM


TWO former members of the Church of Scientology are keen to tell Kevin Rudd and Tony Abbott of their concerns about the church, Independent senator Nick Xenophon says.

Liz and James Anderson have been disconnected from their daughter who they said was being held at the church's headquarters in the United States.

"Here is a chance for the Prime Minister and the Opposition Leader to hear first hand what it is like to be a victim of the Church of Scientology," Senator Xenophon said.

They would be accompanied by a woman who was coerced into having two abortions while she was a member of the church, he said.

The Senate will decide tomorrow whether to back Senator Xenophon's call for an inquiry into the church.

"So I think it's important for Members of Parliament to hear first-hand from these victims before they decide whether there should be an inquiry or not."

Mr and Mrs Anderson will meet some MPs and senators later today, but they wanted to meet directly with Mr Rudd and Mr Abbott, Senator Xenophon said.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/national/former-scientologists-keen-to-spill-beans-on-church-to-rudd-abbott/story-e6frf7l6-1225841737373
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #69 on: March 19, 2010, 07:18:20 AM »

                              Senate rejects Scientology inquiry

The Sydney Morning Herald
March 18, 2010 - 5:09PM

AAP

The Senate has rejected a second call for a parliamentary inquiry into the controversial Church of Scientology, but backers say the issue is gaining traction and have vowed to keep pushing it.

A group of former Scientologists watched from the public gallery as independent senator Nick Xenophon again argued the case for an inquiry on Thursday.

Unlike his failed effort to examine the tax-free status of religious groups including Scientology, this inquiry was to look at specific allegations by former Scientologists, but not their beliefs.

Scientology had engaged in criminal and unconscionable conduct, harassment and stalking, while benefiting from tax-exempt status, Senator Xenophon said.

"This is not about belief systems," he said. "This is about behaviour.

"When we have mounting evidence of cases of abuse, of cases where this organisation says it is above the law because of its own court system ... then I think that's worth looking at."

The motion was defeated 33 votes to 6, with Liberal Bill Heffernan pointedly abstaining.

Senator Xenophon will introduce a third Senate motion when parliament resumes in May.

"I call on my parliamentary colleagues to spend the next month and a half finding out more about these claims of abuse," he said in a statement.

"This will not go away."

He was backed by Australian Greens senator Christine Milne who accused the government and opposition of a cop-out.

Government Senate leader Chris Evans said he was no fan of the Church of Scientology and was "personally open" to an inquiry.

But the government opposed an inquiry for the same reasons it opposed an inquiry into the Exclusive Brethren sect last year - it didn't fit with the Senate's role, he said.

Liberal senator Eric Abetz argued the same point, but urged the Fair Work Ombudsman to examine the organisation's employment practices.

Earlier, parliamentarians seemed to be warming to the idea of an inquiry.

Nationals Senator John Williams left open his support for an inquiry and his colleague, Country-Liberal Party senator Nigel Scullion, said he would lobby his colleagues to support the move, but wouldn't cross the floor.

The Nationals' Barnaby Joyce and Labor MP Jodie Campbell also met a group of former Scientologists outside Parliament House, with Senator Joyce inviting them to a meeting.

The Church of Scientology has welcomed the Senate vote.

"It is not the role of parliament to investigate any religious organisation or seek to use parliament as a forum for an unfounded attack on any religion," it said in a statement.

It said Senator Xenophon's allegations were "utterly without foundation".

"They are rumour and outright lies by individuals levelling scurrilous accusations against their former religion."



http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/senate-rejects-scientology-inquiry-20100318-qgge.html
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #70 on: March 20, 2010, 07:37:23 AM »

Rudd still cold on Scientology probe

By online political correspondent Emma Rodgers

Updated Fri Mar 19, 2010 10:47am AEDT
The Church of Scientology has welcomed the news there will be no inquiry for now

The Church of Scientology has welcomed the news there will be no inquiry for now (AAP: Dean Lewins, file photo)

    * Related Story: Scientology inquiry fails again
    * Related Story: Ex-Scientologist 'pressured' to have abortions
    * Related Story: Scientology insider's nightmare childhood

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd is still cold on the idea of a Senate probe into the Church of Scientology, but has left the door open for possible support for another kind of inquiry.

Independent Senator Nick Xenophon has vowed to make a third push for a Senate inquiry into the Church after last year airing allegations made by ex-members of coerced abortions, criminal activity and abuse.

But both major parties will not support the inquiry, saying the Senate is not the right place to examine criminal allegations.

Mr Rudd has told Channel 7 he still has deep concerns about alleged mistreatment of members but is not convinced a Senate inquiry should go ahead.

"We've got to be very careful about using parliamentary forums to air potentially criminal charges or criminal allegations," he said.

"Let me take some further advice on the separation between general concerns about the Church of Scientology - many of which I deeply share - and on the other hand, allegations of criminality... which are properly left with law enforcement authorities.

"If that's capable of some separation, maybe."

Senator Xenophon has told ABC2 he thinks the Government's position is moving.

"I think that there is a shift in the mood and the language and I'll be working on that in the Parliamentary break," he said.

"Whether there are other options in terms of an independent inquiry, that could be a way forward.

"I still think the the best way forward is to have a Senate inquiry."

The Church has welcomed the news there will be no inquiry for now, saying anyone with allegations of criminal behavior should go to the police.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/03/19/2850384.htm?section=justin
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #71 on: March 21, 2010, 03:43:25 PM »

                          Xenophon certain about Scientology probe
March 21, 2010 - 10:49AM

AAP

Independent senator Nick Xenophon is confident there will be a parliamentary inquiry into the Church of Scientology.

The Senate has twice rejected his calls to launch an inquiry into the organisation, which has been the subject of claims of abuse, including coerced abortions and workplace law breaches.

But Senator Xenophon isn't giving up, and says he's heartened by the change of language on the issue, noting Prime Minister Kevin Rudd's comments on Friday that he too has concerns about the church.

"It's inevitable that there will be some sort of inquiry into the Church of Scientology," he told Network Ten.

"Anything that's of a criminal nature ought to go to the police... but there are a whole range of other issues that can be looked at by a senate inquiry."

These include law reform, health and safety practices, industrial practices, consumer law and reform of the criminal code, he said.

"These victims of Scientology deserve an inquiry, deserve a platform for their concerns to be heard."

© 2010 AAP

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/xenophon-certain-about-scientology-probe-20100321-qnoy.html
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #72 on: March 21, 2010, 03:48:46 PM »

                                Cults should be given nowhere to hide
MICHAEL BACHELARD
March 21, 2010

Despite criminal investigations, these groups continue unfettered.

THE recent evidence of the psychological harm caused by religious cults could not be more graphic.

On ABC TV's Four Corners, Liz and James Anderson told how their indoctrination in Scientology saw them part with hundreds of thousands of dollars buying the outpourings of guru L. Ron Hubbard. Eventually they also lost one of their daughters, signing guardianship to a Scientologist slave labour camp called Sea Org.

Today Tonight then revealed how a NSW-based Exclusive Brethren doctor, Mark Craddock, had chemically castrated a young man to suppress his sex drive because he was gay. When Today Tonight dared to film him with victim Craig Hoyle outside the Brethren headquarters, they were pursued around Sydney by cars full of young thugs who are facing criminal charges.

Despite this latest evidence, the Senate rejected Nick Xenophon's request for an inquiry into Scientology when both major parties voted against it. We've been down this road before. Through much of 2006 and 2007, the Greens tried to get a Senate inquiry into the Exclusive Brethren, and the major parties vetoed it. The Liberal Party's serial cult apologist, Eric Abetz, dismissed the victims of these damaging organisations as people ''voluntarily allowing themselves to be brainwashed''.

This means that, in Australia, cults are thriving under the protection of politicians, the police and the courts.

When it comes to notions of religious freedom, our thinking is dangerously woolly. The only cult indoctrination we take seriously is by Islamic terror groups. The recent counter-terrorism white paper recognised the process of radicalisation that young Muslim men undergo before committing acts of violence.

But the same techniques of coercive persuasion make Scientologists sign away guardianship of their children; have abortions at someone else's demand; or make Exclusive Brethren members teach their children that their estranged father is ''of the devil''.

All this causes damage that is lifelong and debilitating. And yet politicians are petrified of being seen to infringe the right of an apparently religious group to do whatever it wants. We need to ruthlessly tighten up our understanding in this area. The state should only allow a religion as much freedom as the members of that religion themselves enjoy. So unless the faithful are free to argue, to question their leaders, to be gay, to quit and go to another church with their families intact, then the religion itself should be taxed, regulated, should lose school funding and be put out of business.

We could use the International Charter of Human Rights as our model of appropriate behaviour. And we should have a commissioner of religions to enforce the law. Religious freedom should not be granted unconditionally. And by their practices we should know them.

Kevin Rudd and others have urged victims of the Exclusive Brethren to report criminal activity. But the criminal law is not up to dealing with cults. In 1998, the federal government's Model Criminal Code committee recommended that the states and territories rejig assault laws to deal with the effects of cult indoctrination.

The committee said it should be a crime to cause ''harm to a person's mental health, whether temporary or permanent''. All states and territories should put this clause into their crimes act, the committee found.

Then damaged individuals would have an option. At the moment, the only recourse is to sue. A criminal sanction would mean the victim would simply be a witness to a case investigated by police and run by the state.

One or two successful criminal prosecutions and jail terms for cult leaders should be enough to convince the rest of them to allow people to see their children.

But the implementation of that recommendation has been woeful. We need to get it clear that cults that deliberately harm people while they hide behind the skirts of religion are not legitimate. They should not enjoy the protection of the law against their victims. They should not have taxpayer concessions or get government funding for schools. And they should be answerable for their crimes in the dock.

Michael Bachelard is a senior Sunday Age journalist and author of Behind the Exclusive Brethren.

mbachelard@theage.com.au.

http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/society-and-culture/cults-should-be-given-nowhere-to-hide-20100320-qn87.html
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #73 on: March 22, 2010, 08:47:27 PM »

                     Not all grievances are created equal in politics
MARK DAVIS
March 19, 2010


                                 The Sydney Morning Herald


When allegations emerged that shonky insulation installers operating under the Federal Government's home insulation program had exposed householders to the risk of fires and workers to injury or death, the Liberal and National Parties promptly referred the matter to a Senate inquiry.

And when trade unions claimed that Australia Post was cutting its workers compensation costs by using company doctors to force injured employees back to work prematurely, the Labor Party was more than willing to ask a Senate committee to inquire.

But yesterday, despite credible accounts tabled in Parliament of harassment, assault and fraud by the Church of Scientology, Labor, Liberal and National Senators all joined forces to defeat a move by the South Australian independent Senator Nick Xenophon for an inquiry.

You might have thought the role of Senate committees should include investigating serious grievances and claims of mistreatment by citizens who have nowhere else to go because of gaps in the legal system.

But not all grievances, it seems, are created equal.

The Opposition is more interested in allegations which lend themselves to political point-scoring against the Government. The Government, in turn, prefers Senate inquiries which give its allies in the union movement a forum to ventilate industrial grievances.

Senator Xenophon first raised his concerns about Scientology in the Senate last November.

He tabled letters from former members, officials and staff alleging abusive practices inside the Church including assault, imprisonment, torture, covering up sexual abuse, blackmail and embezzlement.

Senator Xenophon said then that he wanted a Senate inquiry into the allegations by these "victims of Scientology."

He had the backing of the Greens. But Labor and Liberal senators warned him informally that they would be wary about anything smacking of intruding upon religious freedom.

So last week Senator Xenophon moved for the Senate's economics references committee to examine whether tax exemptions under federal law for charitable and religious organisations (including Scientology) should be subject to a public interest test.

His tactic was to frame an inquiry in the narrowest of terms, focussing on the issue of tax exemptions to avoid accusations he wanted a witch-hunt into Scientology.

But that did not stop the major parties from voting down Senator Xenophon's first motion last Thursday.

The Special Minister of State, Joe Ludwig, said the government would not support the motion because there had already been several inquiries into the tax treatment of charitable organisations and there was no need for another.

Having been rebuffed for framing his inquiry too narrowly, even though he had been advised to do so to attract wider support, Senator Xenophon returned to the fray yesterday.

This time he moved a motion asking the economics committee to inquire into:

* allegations of abuse by the Church of Scientology including coerced abortions, unsafe occupational health and safety practices, unconscionable, misleading and deceptive conduct in its provision of goods and services, and harassment of followers and ex-followers;

* the adequacy of the Model Criminal Code in respect of the offence of psychological harm;

* the adequacy of consumer protection laws in respect of fundraising and provision of goods and services by Scientology;

* the adequacy of occupational health and safety laws and workplace relations laws in respect of conduct inside the Church.

The motion ruled out any examination of the validity of Scientology's beliefs systems.

Once again, Government and Opposition senators and the Victorian Family First senator Steve Fielding, joined forces to outvote Senator Xenophon and the five Greens, torpedoing any inquiry.

Opposition frontbencher Eric Abetz said allegations of illegality should be dealt with by authorities like the police or the Fair Work Ombudsman rather than a Senate inquiry.

That stance is inconsistent with the Opposition's approach to allegations of illegality under the home insulation program which it has pursued with alacrity in Parliament despite the relevant coronial and workplace health and safety authorities having their own examinations on foot.

The Government's Senate leader Chris Evans had a different rationale. He said the role of Senate committees was to inquire into matters of public policy and government administration, not into individual organisations.

"It is a very dangerous thing for us to have what could be seen as a witch-hunt against an individual organisation, be it a religion, a trade union, a community organisation or a company," Senator Evans said.

Executives at Australia Post must be surprised to hear Senator Evans invoke a rule against Senate inquiries into individual companies after Labor joined with the minor parties last October to refer allegations over Post's health and safety practices to a Senate committee.

And the Australian Football League must wonder why Labor initiated a Senate inquiry in 2008 into whether its decision to admit new teams from western Sydney and the Gold Coast, before a team from Tasmania, was fair and equitable.

Cults have long shielded unsavoury activities from external scrutiny under the guise of religious freedom.

But with the heightened influence of religion on politics in Australia in recent years, this tactic is now working more effectively for the Scientologists.

Back in 1985 this reporter covered a debate in the South Australian Parliament's upper house on the report of a select committee which had conducted a 10-month inquiry into Scientology and found evidence the Church had ripped off people financially.

As the debate unfolded a congregation of Scientologists, all clad in black, crammed into the Legislative Council's public gallery and stood there, staring intently at MPs as they spoke.

Eventually the leader of the SA Australian Democrats, the late Lance Milne, complained to the President of the Council, saying he believed the Scientologists were trying to hypnotise him.

The Scientologists were warned in no uncertain terms that they would be ejected if they continued attempting to intimidate Parliamentarians and soon backed off.

Now, 25 years later, the tables have been turned.

http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/not-all-grievances-are-created-equal-in-politics-20100319-qiws.html
Logged
Ididntcomeback
Regulars
Hero Member
*****

Karma: +13/-0
Online Online

Posts: 1733


« Reply #74 on: March 27, 2010, 02:00:50 PM »

                      Church briefing on Senator Xenophon and Parliament
                            Copied from EXSMB


I received this e-mail today.


Ideal Org Briefing
Russell Street Org

Manny Foundas, President of the Church of Scientology Melbourne is giving a briefing on Senator Xenophon and Parliament. He will give a plan of action for all of us to do with regards to these attacks on our Church.
There will also be an update from Errol on the renovations of Ascot Vale.

DIRECTIONS: URGENT!
This Friday 26th March there are events that will affect you getting to the Org.
GRAND PRIX, AFL FOOTY & GREEK FESTIVAL
Please avoid St.Kilda Road, Punt Road, Russell Street
If you are coming from the South East get on to the SE freeway and exit at Batman Ave, then up Exhibition Street. From the East come on the Eastern Fwy and avoid Punt Road. Come to Exhibition Street.
Please Call Pauline 96548654

© 2010 CSAusInc. All Rights Reserved. Scientology L RON HUBBARD and DIANETICS are Trademarks and Service marks owned Religious Technology Center and used with its permission. Services relating to Scientology are delivered throughout the world exclusively by licensees of the Church of Scientology International with the permission of Religious Technology Center, holder of the SCIENTOLOGY and DIANETICS trademarks

http://www.forum.exscn.net/showthread.php?t=17111

"Attacks on our church" !!!!

Firstly it isn`t a church.
And since when did exposing the truth constitute being an attack ???
Logged
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5] 6 7 ... 9   Go Up
Print
Jump to: